Statistics, Damn Statistics, and Bullocks - the true picture
The hoo-ha over the latest survey of ASDA’s commitment to British sourcing doesn’t add up.
The National Farmers Union (England & Wales) and one of the beef groups have lined up behind the English Beef and Lamb Executive’s assessment of what’s on our shelves.
Now, we don’t have any difficulties with this at all. In fact, the NFU have repeatedly surveyed our stores looking at the labelling we use. We have an excellent working arrangement with the team that do the work and the NFU seem happy with the approach.
However EBLEX have taken a sample of their findings from a fraction of our stores and extended this to quantify a total purchase of British beef. Itâ€™s a bit like a bran tub dip and gives a predictably unreliable result.
So while on any given day you can find higher % of imported products on a shelf; firstly, those products are always clearly labelled so there is no confusion for customers.
Secondly, unless EBLEX were there all day from when we first started stacking shelves until the last customer has left the store, the shelf contents will never accurately reflect what we buy. The proportion of products on shelf change as a result of customers picking up products. Possibly even, taking British in preference!
And just to clarify the most meaningful statistic of all, in 2008 ASDA sold more than 25000 kg of British Beef. The same period in 2009, we have sold more than 25000 kg.
Had anyone from EBLEX thought to ask, we could have told them this months ago and saved them the effort and expense of conducting a flawed survey.